We need to identify what metrics we currently have on updates and improve them to where they match the Board's vision for updates:
"Project members should be able to transparently measure or monitor a new updates process to objectively measure its effectiveness, and determine whether the updates process is achieving the aforementioned vision statements."
Luke: Can you run what you have for bodhi stats again against all the old releases you have so we see where we are?
= Fedora 12 =
= Fedora 13 =
= Fedora 14 =
= Fedora EPEL 5 =
= Fedora EPEL 4 =
= Totals = Out of 13762 total updates, 3864 received feedback (28.08%) Out of 972 total unique karma submitters, the top 20 are: * adamwill (201) * filiperosset (194) * kevin (194) * jdulaney (184) * masami (171) * mrunge (169) * shinobi (155) * boblfoot (144) * bernie (127) * cweyl (126) * watzkej (114) * redwolfe (108) * notting (102) * salimma (94) * mschwendt (90) * kwright (84) * mtasaka (73) * robatino (71) * genes (66) * mooninite (59)
Kyle is going to look at these and see if we can adjust or add any needed by fesco. Thanks.
Many updates get edited and go through more than one "revision" (is that the proper term?). I would like to see the number of old revisions and how many of them got pushed to testing. It might be useful to combine these numbers with the number of obsolete updates.
kylem is going to look at this some.
Fresh metrics!
== Fedora 15 ==
== Fedora 14 ==
== Fedora 13 ==
== Fedora EPEL 6 ==
== Fedora EPEL 5 ==
== Fedora EPEL 4 ==
== Totals == * Out of 23574 total updates, 6599 received feedback (27.99%) * Out of 1218 total unique karma submitters, the top 50 are: * autoqa (1340) * notting (426) * adamwill (361) * mclasen (360) * jkeating (322) * masami (227) * rdieter (215) * filiperosset (192) * cwickert (183) * jdulaney (183) * mooninite (177) * pbrobinson (167) * tomspur (162) * boblfoot (144) * mtasaka (143) * cweyl (126) * cschwangler (123) * shinobi (115) * redwolfe (110) * peter (107) * xake (101) * tagoh (92) * mschwendt (88) * michich (88) * kwright (84) * hadess (83) * robatino (83) * salimma (78) * bpepple (78) * thomasj (76) * pravins (76) * dp67 (73) * remi (73) * sundaram (73) * athmane (72) * oget (72) * mhlavink (71) * spot (69) * alexlan (69) * raven (69) * kkofler (68) * fab (67) * dwalsh (66) * twaugh (62) * orion (61) * kwizart (60) * robert (57) * limb (55) * nphilipp (52) * jonathan11 (51)
Here are some fresh metrics with some new proventester data.
Fedora 14
================================================================================
================================================================================ Fedora 15 ================================================================================
================================================================================ Fedora 16 ================================================================================
Out of 23255 total updates, 6375 received feedback (27.41%) Out of 1259 total unique karma submitters, the top 50 are: * autoqa (28787) * kevin (861) * adamwill (719) * ausil (580) * caillon (545) * masami (474) * mschwendt (357) * mrunge (354) * athmane (290) * boblfoot (257) * robatino (249) * watzkej (246) * ellert (228) * kalev (220) * peter (216) * bernie (214) * jdulaney (208) * robert (190) * filiperosset (179) * salimma (177) * stevetraylen (175) * redwolfe (167) * mtasaka (167) * lmacken (164) * shinobi (160) * notting (158) * raven (156) * rdieter (140) * oldfart (132) * orion (131) * pbrobinson (128) * kwright (122) * nb (116) * jlaska (109) * tflink (108) * petersen (106) * mooninite (102) * remi (102) * bojan (99) * evillagr (99) * jussilehtola (96) * iarnell (95) * mclasen (95) * antiaircraft (92) * bpepple (92) * tomspur (91) * norbot (87) * kkofler (85) * elad (84) * rjones (84)
}}}
I don't think we've done anything substantial with this. I also don't think the past two Boards have cared about this at all.
Fedora has a lot of updates. It's a product of our release cycle.
Is there any reason to keep this open?
No answer to Josh's question so I'm closing this. Feel free to open a new ticket if the situation changes.
Login to comment on this ticket.